About DrillingFormulas.Com

Working in the oil field and loving to share knowledge.

What is the difference between drill solids and barite?

Learn the difference between drill solids and barite and how these 2 kinds of weighting material will affect drilling operation.

Drill Solid: It is solid particles from formation generated while drilling. Its specific gravity is about 2.6 which is normally defined as Low Gravity Solid (LGS). Drill solid can increase mud weight; however, it will degrade mud properties such as Yield Point, viscosity, gel strength, etc. If mud excessively gets drill solid, drilling fluid properties especially rheology (Yield Point, viscosity) will be higher and mud cake with a lot of drill solid will be poor quality. Higher rheology will lead to more required energy in order to make circulation. In addition, poor mud cake can also lead to pipe struck situation.

In order to control drill solid content in mud, solid control equipment as shale shakers, desanders, desilters and centrifuges must be operated properly and effectively.

Barite: It is the weighting agent with specific gravity about 4.2 normally called High Gravity Solid. Both Drill solid and Barite are able to be weighting agent; however, Barite does not degrade other mud properties such as PV, YP, gel strength, etc.

Reference books: Drilling Fluid Books

Drilling Fluid Properties

Drilling fluid properties are essential information that everybody should understand.

Density: Mud density is the weight per unit volume of mud and normally it is reported in Pound Per Gallon (PPG). Mud density is used for providing hydrostatic pressure to control well for drilling operation.

Viscosity: It is defined as the internal resistance of fluid flow. There are 2 types of viscosity which are Funnel Viscosity and Plastic Viscosity.

1) Funnel Viscosity: It is time, in seconds for one quart of mud to flow through a Marsh funnel which has a capacity of 946 cm3 (See Figure 1). A quart of water exits the funnel in 26 seconds. This is not a true viscosity, but serves as a qualitative measure of how thick the mud sample is. The funnel viscosity is useful only for relative comparisons.

Figure 1 Marsh Funnel

2) Plastic Viscosity (PV): A parameter of the Bingham plastic rheological model (See Figure 3). PV is the slope of the shear stress-shear rate plot above the yield point (See Figure 4). Viscometer is equipment to measure Plastic Viscosity (See Figure 2). Plastic Viscosity is derived from the 600 rpm reading minus the 300 rpm reading and PV is in centipoises (cp). A low PV indicates that the mud is capable of drilling rapidly because of the low viscosity of mud exiting at the bit. High PV is caused by a viscous base fluid and by excess colloidal solids. To lower PV, a reduction in solids content can be achieved by dilution.

There are many rheology models shown in Figure 3. Normally Bingham Plastic Model is used to describe mud properties as Plastic Viscosity and Yield Point (See Figure 4).

Figure 2 Viscometer

Figure 3 Rheology Model (Ref  slb.com)

Figure 4 Bingham Plastic Model describes PY and VP

Yield Point: Physical meaning is the resistance to initial flow, or the stress required starting fluid movement. The Bingham plastic fluid plots as a straight line on a shear-rate (x-axis) versus shear stress (y-axis) plot, in which YP is the zero-shear-rate intercept (PV is the slope of the line). YP is calculated from 300-rpm and 600-rpm viscometer dial readings by subtracting PV from the 300-rpm dial reading and it is reported as lbf/100 ft2. YP is used to evaluate the ability of mud to lift cuttings out of the annulus. A higher YP implies that drilling fluid has ability to carry cuttings better than a fluid of similar density but lower YP.

Gel Strength: It is the ability of fluid to suspend fluid while mud is in static condition. Before testing gel strength, mud must be agitated for awhile in order to prevent precipitation and then let mud is in static condition for a certain limited time (10 seconds, 10 minutes or maybe 30 minutes) and then open the viscometer at 3 rpm and read the maximum reading value. In a morning report, there are 3 values of gel strength, which are Gel 10sec (lbf/100 ft2), Gel 10 mins (lbf/100 ft2) and Gel 30 mins (lbf/100 ft2).

Ph: This value tells the acid of drilling fluid. Ph paper is used to measure Ph.

Electrical Stability (ES): This value reflects to the stability of emulsion of SDF. If water disperses well in oil phase (good emulsion), the resistivity of drilling fluid will be higher. In contrast, if water disperses badly in oil phase (bad emulsion), the resistivity of drilling fluid will be lower. As the concept above, applied Ohm’s law (V=IR), electricity from the electrical stability meter is emitted in to mud and voltage is measured by the electrical probe. Normally if the measured voltage is higher than 500 volt, the electrical stability is good.

Figure 5 Electrical Stability Meter

CaCl2 Concentration: Cl+ can prevent formation swell hence this value must be maintained. It is measured by a titration test by using silver nitrate as titrant with potassium chromate as the endpoint indicator and when titration reaches the equilibrium point mud will change into red.

Retort Test: There are 2 values that are Saraline Water Ratio (SWR) and Solid Content (LGS, Barite) obtained from this testing. Mud is retorted in retort test skid at 950 F for 2 hrs. High temperature can vaporize liquid phase into gas phase and then gas phase will be transferred to a condenser and condense in liquid form. Liquid is stored in a tube that has a level indicator to see how much of water and oil (saraline) extracted. Moreover, solid left in the retort reflects the solid content in mud.

Figure 6 Retort Test Skid

HTHP Fluid Loss: This test is conducted for testing fluid loss behavior of mud. Mud is pressed through filter paper located in the HTHP filter press at 300 F with differential pressure at 500 psi for 30 mins. Thickness of filter cake stuck in filter paper should be less than 2 ml.

Figure 7 HTHP filter press

Reference books: Drilling Fluid Books

Causes of Kick (Wellbore Influx)

A “Kick” or “Wellbore Influx” is undesirable flow of formation fluid into the wellbore and it happens when formation pressure is more than hydrostatic pressure in wellbore.

Deepwater Horizon offshore drilling unit on fire 2010

Deepwater Horizon offshore drilling unit on fire 2010 (Wiki)

Several causes of Kick (Wellbore Influx) are listed below:

1. Lack of knowledge and experience of personnel (Human error)– Lacking of well-trained personnel can cause well control incident because they don’t have any ideas what can cause well control problem. For example, personnel may accidentally pump lighter fluid into wellbore and if the fluid is light enough, reservoir pressure can overcome hydrostatic pressure.

2. Light density fluid in wellbore It results in decreasing hydrostatic pressure. There are several reasons that can cause this issue such as

• Light pills, sweep, spacer in hole

• Accidental dilution of drilling fluid

• Gas cut mud

3. Abnormal pressure – If abnormally high pressure zones are over current mud weight in the well, eventually kick will occur.

4. Unable to keep the hole full all the time while drilling and tripping. If hole is not full with drilling fluid, overall hydrostatic pressure will decrease.

5. Severe lost circulation – Due to lost circulation in formation, if  the well could not be kept fully filled all the time, hydrostatic pressure will be decreased.

Lost circulation usually caused when the hydrostatic pressure of drilling fluid exceeds formation pressure. There are several factors that can cause lost circulation such as

• Mud properties – mud weight is too heavy and too viscous.

• High Equivalent Circulating Density

• High surge pressure due to tripping in hole so fast

• Drilling into weak formation strength zone

6. Swabbing causes reducing wellbore hydrostatic pressure.

Swabbing is the condition that happens when anything in a hole such as drill string, logging tool, completion sting, etc is pulled and it brings out decreasing hydrostatic pressure. Anyway, swabbing can be recognized while pulling out of hole by closely monitoring hole fill in trip sheet.

Reference book: Well Control Books

Functions of Drilling Fluid

You may not know that drilling fluid or mud has several important functions helping us achieve goal to drill well. I would like to share about the functions of drilling fluid as follows;

1. Transport cutting and dispose to surface The drilling fluid brings the drilled material to the ground surface either by mud rheology and velocity.

2. Clean drill bitsAs drilling fluid exits the bit jets, fluid velocity removes cutting from the bit teeth and bit body. This prevents bit ball up situation.

3. Provide hydrostatic pressure to control well while drillingHydrostatic pressure provided from drilling fluid is the primary well control. Mud weight should be high enough to control formation pressure while drilling.

4. Prevent excessive mud loss While drilling, clay particle will form a thin layer over porous zones called “mud cake” or “filter cake”. Mud cake acts as barrier to prevent excessive drilling fluid loss into formation and provides wellbore stability.

5. Prevent formation damage by using reservoir drill-in fluidWhile drilling long reach zone in horizontal wells, the special drilling fluid will be utilized in order to prevent formation damage.

6. Provide hydraulic pressure to downhole assembly (BHA) as mud motor, measuring while drilling (MWD), logging while drilling (LWD), etcWithout enough hydraulic power, downhole tool will not be properly operated, hence, drilling fluid plays essential role to provide power to sophisticated downhole tool.

7. Facilitate downhole measurement as open hole logging, MWD, LWD, mud logging, etcMud will assist tool to measure everything downhole.

8. Lubricate drill string and BHA and cool the bit. The drill bit and BHA become hot due to friction during the drilling process. When the drilling fluid passes through the bit and exits the jets/nozzles, some extra heat is removed via mud.

Reference books: Drilling Fluid Books

Boyle’s Gas Law and Its Application in Drilling

Understand Boyle’s Gas Law

Boyle’s gas law states that at constant temperature, the absolute pressure and the volume of a gas are inversely proportional in case of constant temperature within a closed system.  Bolye’s law can be illustrate in the graph shown in figure 1.

Figure 1 – Boyle’s Law

Well, we can describe the statement above into simple mathematics as following formula:

Boyle’s Gas Law

P x V = constant

Or express Boyle’s law in another term:

P1 x V1 = P2 x V2

Where;

P1 = Pressure at condition # 1

 V1 = Volume at condition # 1

P2 = Pressure at condition # 2

 V2 = Volume at condition # 2

Note: You can use any unit for Bolye’s gas law as long as P1 and P2 are the same unit and V1 and V2 are the same unit.

Let’s apply Boyle’s law into our drilling business

Calculate the volume of gas you will have on the surface, 14.7 psi for atmospheric pressure, when 1 bbl of gas kick is circulated out from reservoir where has formation pressure of 3,000 psi. Figure 2 and 3 shows the condition of this well.

Figure 2 – Gas Kick 1st condition at the bottom

Figure 3 – Gas Kick 2nd condition

Apply the Boyle’s Gas Law:

P1 x V1 = P2 x V2

P1= 3000 psi (reservoir pressure)

V1 = 1 bbl (volume at bottom hole)

P2 = 14.7 psi (atmosphere pressure)

V2 = ? (volume at surface)

P1 x V1 = P2 x V2

3000 x 1 = 14.7 x V2

V2 = 204 bbl

Figure 4 – Gas

References

Cormack, D. (2007). An introduction to well control calculations for drilling operations. 1st ed. Texas: Springer.

Crumpton, H. (2010). Well Control for Completions and Interventions. 1st ed. Texas: Gulf Publishing.

Grace, R. (2003). Blowout and well control handbook [recurso electrónico]. 1st ed. Paises Bajos: Gulf Professional Pub.

Grace, R. and Cudd, B. (1994). Advanced blowout & well control. 1st ed. Houston: Gulf Publishing Company.

Watson, D., Brittenham, T. and Moore, P. (2003). Advanced well control. 1st ed. Richardson, Tex.: Society of Petroleum Engineers.